Innovation Catalyst Challenge Game

Photo by christian buehner on Unsplash
Innovation Catalyst Challenge
Imagine introducing C-Level executives—or anyone unfamiliar with Product Mindset, Design Thinking, Innovation, and Customer Centricity—to the core of these concepts. Now imagine doing it in just 20 minutes. Sounds like a daunting task, doesn’t it?
That’s the challenge I recently faced. The goal was to design a game that would not only engage these C-Level executives but also offer a concise yet comprehensive experience of these vital business concepts.
In this blog, I’ll walk you through the game’s essential elements, provide step-by-step instructions, and offer facilitation tips for those eager to take the lead. And, there are ready-to-print PDFs waiting for you to bring this game to life. Dive in and enjoy!
Considerations, Planning and Preparation
Below are my considerations while planning and preparing this game:
# | Consideration | Description |
---|---|---|
1 | Scenarios | Crafting scenarios that are simultaneously realistic and challenging is crucial. This approach ensures authentic engagement from participants and serves as a true test of their abilities. Scenarios should be adapted to reflect the industry of the participants, ensuring relatability. To inject an element of competition and enhance engagement, participants will be grouped into teams. Every team starts with the same scenario. |
2 | Decision-Making | Participants will receive hypothetical data, customer feedback, or other resources during the game. They will then be tasked with making decisions based on this information. Participants can use a Whiteboard (or Flip chart) and Sticky notes if they wish. They’re also encouraged to engage in team discussions before arriving at a final decision, fostering collaboration. |
3 | Time Limit | To mimic the pressures of real-time decision-making, each stage of the game has a time constraint. It’s vital to strike a balance: ensuring urgency while allowing enough time for thoughtful decisions. |
4 | Game Coins | Each team is given a set number of game coins at the outset, simulating a realistic environment where resources are finite. This adds a strategic dimension, prompting teams to make judicious resource allocations. |
5 | Adaptability | For those aiming to elevate their game, participants can devise their own strategies instead of following prescribed routes, within the given timeframe. This choice affects time, quality, and the expenditure of game coins. Offering scenarios with varying complexity ensures the game remains challenging for participants of all expertise levels. |
6 | Outcome Measurement | The game culminates in a showcase session where teams elucidate their strategies. Participants will explain their decision-making processes, and a defined criteria set will assess team outcomes—focusing on innovation, customer focus, resource management, and solution practicality. |
7 | Feedback | Following the showcase, teams receive feedback either from the audience or a judging panel. This feedback is invaluable for learning, helping teams recognize their strengths and areas of improvement. |
8 | Debrief and Key Learnings | Post-game, a debriefing session highlights the primary lessons and insights garnered from the experience. It offers a moment of reflection—on strategies employed, decisions made, and how these lessons can be applied in real-world contexts. By the game’s end, participants should grasp the significance of a product mindset in delivering customer-centric results. They’ll also gain hands-on experience in data-informed decision-making, team collaboration under pressure, and both critical and creative thinking. |
9 | Prizes and Recognition | To sustain participant enthusiasm, the winning team receives prizes. These rewards can be tangible or recognition certificates, instilling a sense of achievement in participants. |
Crafting the Scenarios
Designing the game scenarios requires meticulous preparation. It’s not a task to rush—ensure you are well-prepared.
- Scenario Development: Dedicate time to curate scenarios resonating with your target audience. Ideally, prepare a minimum of three scenarios for each industry. This offers participants a choice, ensuring engagement, and serves as a contingency should some scenarios not resonate with all.
- Deep Dive Research: For each scenario, develop a clear Hypothesis, OKRs, Personas, Touch Points & Considerations, Feature Sets, Dependencies, Tech Stack Options, and Product Release Strategies.
Materials Needed
- Timer
- Whiteboard (or Flip chart)
- Whiteboard Markers
- Permanent Markers
- Sticky notes
- Game coins
Game Play: Step-by-Step Guide
- Starting Choices: Lay out the three Key Scenarios on the table, allowing each team to select their preferred challenge.
- Forming Teams: Once a scenario is selected, segment the participants into dynamic teams, ideally comprising 3-4 members each.
- Scenario Briefing: Distribute a scenario card to each group. This card paints the picture of a distinct industry challenge, complete with the nuances of the digital solution it demands and the objectives that must be fulfilled.
- Rule Book: Take a moment to elucidate the game’s rules, ensuring all participants are clear on the game’s mechanics and expectations.
- Beat the Clock: Initiate a 20-minute countdown, signaling the start of the creative process.
- Collaborative Brainstorming: Motivate teams to engage in vibrant brainstorming sessions, challenging and building upon each other’s ideas. Equip them with tools like Sticky notes, Whiteboards, or Flip charts to map out their thoughts.
- Facilitator’s Role: As they immerse themselves, maintain an active presence. Wander around, observing the teams’ dynamics and progress. While your primary role is as an observer, be available for guidance or clarity, yet allow participants the autonomy to steer their discussions.
- Show and Tell: Once the timer rings out, it’s time for each team to step into the spotlight. Invite them to share their digital solution with everyone, emphasizing the problem they’re addressing, the innovation behind their solution, and how they’ve woven in principles of product mindset, design thinking, and customer centricity.
Game Rules & Guidelines
Here are the rules of the game:
- The Clock is Ticking: Teams have just 20 minutes to brainstorm and propose a digital solution based on their specific scenario. Efficiency and focus are key.
- Core Principles: Solutions aren’t just about quick thinking—they must also embody principles of product mindset, design thinking, and customer centricity. The final proposal should reflect these considerations.
- Resource Management: Every tool and insight comes with a cost, detailed in the table below. Teams will be allotted 15 Innovation Catalyst Game Coins ICG to purchase resources they need during the game. Resourcefulness is rewarded—the winning team may well be the one that manages its ICG$ most effectively.
- Against the Clock: Need more time? Teams can opt for a 2-minute extension, but it comes at a price—deducted from their ICG$ balance.
Price Chart: Expenditure Guide for Resources
# | Resource | Cost |
---|---|---|
1 | Hypothesis | ICG$ 1 |
2 | OKR | ICG$ 1 |
3 | Persona | ICG$ 2 |
4 | Pain points, Preferences, and Behaviour | ICG$ 3 |
5 | Touch Points & Considerations | ICG$ 2 |
6 | Product Backlog | ICG$ 1 |
7 | Prioritised Product Backlog | ICG$ 3 |
8 | Tech Stack Options | ICG$ 2 |
9 | 2-minute extension | ICG$ 2 |
Sample Game Play
Considering many of my participants come from the Financial Services Industry, I will now share a unique scenario I created specifically for the Banking sector.
Financial Wellness Platform
Here is a brief description of the “Financial Wellness Platform” scenario that I created for my participants.
Scenario: Financial Wellness Platform
Problem | Objective |
---|---|
Many customers struggle with managing their personal finances, leading to financial stress and suboptimal financial decisions. | Develop a digital solution that offers personalised financial wellness advice, budgeting tools, and goal tracking to help customers make better financial decisions and improve their overall financial health. |
Hypothesis
- Customers who are actively seeking to reduce debt or save for specific goals (e.g., retirement, home purchase) will be more engaged with the platform and more likely to recommend it to others.
- Access to educational resources on financial literacy and well-being positively impacts users’ financial behaviours and decision-making.
- Customers prefer personalised financial advice tailored to their unique financial situation and goals, rather than generic advice and recommendations.
Success Metrics
To validate the success of the hypothesis, let’s identify the Objectives and the Key Metrics.
Objective 1: Increase user engagement and satisfaction
# | Key Results |
---|---|
1 | Achieve a 20% increase in average user session duration within the next 6 months. |
2 | Improve the platform’s Net Promoter Score (NPS) by 15 points within the next 6 months. |
3 | Increase the percentage of users achieving their financial goals by 25% within the next 12 months. |
Objective 2: Expand the user base and market presence
# | Key Results |
---|---|
1 | Acquire 10,000 new users within the next 6 months. |
2 | Increase the conversion rate of new users to paid subscribers by 10% within the next 6 months. |
3 | Launch targeted marketing campaigns for each user segment, resulting in a 15% increase in overall brand awareness within the next 12 months. |
Persona
Creating a persona is the next step to empathise and understand the actual needs.
User Persona | Age | Occupation | Marital Status | Income | Goals |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Budget-Conscious Brenda | 32 | Marketing Manager | Single | $130,000 per year | Pay off student loans, save for a down payment on a house |
Retirement-Ready Robert | 55 | Small Business Owner | Married with two grown children | $300,000 per year | Maximise retirement savings, diversify investments |
Freelance Fiona | 28 | Freelance Graphic Designer | Living with partner | $70,000 per year (variable) | Build an emergency fund, save for a vacation |
Debt-Determined Dan | 40 | IT Consultant | Divorced, one child | $140,000 per year | Eliminate credit card debt, save for child’s college education |
Savings-Savvy Sarah | 25 | Entry-Level Engineer | Single | $55,000 per year | Save for a new car, establish an emergency fund |
Pain points, Preferences, and Behaviours
User Persona | Pain points | Preferences | Behaviours |
---|---|---|---|
Budget-Conscious Brenda | Difficulty sticking to a budget, managing multiple financial accounts | Easy-to-use budgeting tools, mobile app for financial tracking | Actively searches for budgeting tips, often reviews her finances but struggles to maintain a consistent budget |
Retirement-Ready Robert | Unsure of how much to save for retirement, needs investment advice | Retirement planning tools, access to expert financial advice | Researches investment options, attends financial planning seminars, seeks professional guidance on retirement savings |
Freelance Fiona | Irregular income, difficulty tracking expenses | Tools for tracking irregular income, customisable budget categories | Adjusts spending based on income fluctuations, struggles to maintain a consistent savings plan due to variable income |
Debt-Determined Dan | High-interest debt, needs guidance on debt repayment strategy | Debt repayment calculators, tips for reducing expenses and interest rates | Makes extra payments towards debt when possible, researches debt consolidation options, seeks advice on effective repayment strategies |
Savings-Savvy Sarah | Limited financial knowledge, unsure of how to allocate savings | Educational resources, goal tracking, and recommendations for saving | Reads personal finance blogs, sets up automatic savings transfers, seeks guidance on effective saving strategies |
For our demonstration, let’s choose “Retirement Ready Robert”.
Retirement Ready Robert
Touch points and Considerations
Mapping the customer journey for the Financial Wellness Platform involves identifying each step users take while interacting with the platform and noting the touch points and areas for improvement. We will consider the customer journey for each persona.
Step | Touchpoint | Consideration |
---|---|---|
Awareness | Robert hears about the platform from a friend who has successfully planned their retirement. | Use targeted email campaigns to reach potential users. |
Consideration | Robert visits the website and reads about the retirement planning features and success stories. | Create video testimonials featuring satisfied users. |
Sign-up | Robert signs up and inputs his financial information, retirement goals, and risk tolerance. | Enhance user guidance during the sign-up process. |
Exploration | Robert explores various retirement calculators, investment tools, and educational resources on the platform. | Curate personalised content and resources based on user needs. |
Engagement | Robert creates a personalised retirement plan and monitors his investments using the platform. | Offer more retirement planning resources, webinars, and personalised retirement coaching. |
Feedback & Support | Robert seeks advice on investment options and receives helpful guidance from the support team. | Develop a comprehensive knowledge base for self-help. |
Advocacy | Robert shares his positive experience with the platform on a retirement-focused online forum. | Encourage users to share their success stories on social media. |
Personal Financial Management & Planning Solution
- Personalised dashboard: Allows Robert to get an overview of his financial situation, especially concerning his retirement savings and investments.
- Comprehensive financial management tools (budgeting, expense tracking, savings goals, investment tracking): These will provide Robert with a holistic picture and help him track and manage his retirement savings and investments.
- Goal setting and tracking: With his goal to maximize retirement savings and diversify investments, Robert would greatly benefit from tools that allow him to set, monitor, and adjust his financial goals.
- Financial advice:
- Personalised financial advice based on data analytics and machine learning algorithms: Helps Robert in making informed decisions about his investments and retirement savings.
- Educational resources to improve financial literacy and promote financial well-being: Assists Robert in understanding the intricacies of retirement planning and other financial topics.
- In-house wealth management services or robo-advisory features: Provides expert guidance tailored to Robert’s financial situation and retirement goals.
- Community features: As someone who seeks professional guidance on retirement savings, Robert can benefit from social sharing and community features, which allow him to interact with peers and experts, share experiences, and learn from others.
- Enhanced User Experience & Integration: Robert would appreciate a platform that integrates seamlessly with other financial services, offers inclusive features suitable for a diverse range of users, and provides multilingual support.
- Specialised Financial Management: Given Robert’s pain points and preferences, specialized tools focusing on retirement planning, irregular income management (as a small business owner), and other financial tasks would be essential. Features such as tax planning would be particularly valuable for him as a high earner.
- Offline Consultation & Personalised Services: Access to exclusive promotions and discounts from financial institutions would appeal to Robert, given his substantial income. Furthermore, the option of physical branches or offices would cater to his preference for seeking professional guidance, allowing him to have face-to-face consultations.
In the touchpoints and considerations:
- Awareness: The “Community features” can be leveraged here, as Robert hears about the platform from a friend.
- Consideration: Emphasise “Specialized Financial Management” tools and features as Robert reads about the retirement planning options.
- Sign-up: Ensure the “Personalised dashboard” and “Comprehensive financial management tools” are highlighted to Robert.
- Exploration: Robert can benefit from “Financial advice” features, especially the educational resources and personalised advice based on machine learning.
- Engagement: “Goal setting and tracking” features, along with specialised retirement planning resources, would be most relevant.
- Feedback & Support: The in-house wealth management and advisory features would be vital here, as Robert seeks advice.
- Advocacy: The “Community features” can come into play again, as Robert shares his experiences on forums.
Product Backlog - Feature Sets
With that, we now have a list of features to be developed.
- Comprehensive financial management tools (budgeting, expense tracking, savings goals, investment tracking)
- Gamification and behavioural incentives to encourage better financial habits and user engagement
- Push notifications and reminders for bill payments, savings goals, and other financial tasks
- Personalised financial advice based on data analytics and machine learning algorithms
- Educational resources to improve financial literacy and promote financial well-being
- In-house wealth management services or robo-advisory features
- Social sharing and community features to foster peer support and learning
- Seamless integration with third-party financial services
- Accessibility and inclusivity, ensuring a wide range of users can benefit from the platform
- Multilingual support for additional languages
- Specialised tools for diverse needs (e.g., irregular income management, debt reduction, retirement planning)
- Additional tools for specific financial tasks, such as tax planning or college savings
- Partnerships with financial institutions to offer exclusive promotions and discounts to users
- Physical branches or offices for in-person financial consultations
Before rolling our sleeves and start developing the feature sets, let’s prioritise the Product Backlog
Prioritised Product Backlog
To prioritise features and enhancements for MyFinancialWellness, we will use the MoSCoW method, which categorises features into four groups: Must-have, Should-have, Could-have, and Won’t-have. This prioritisation considers customer needs, market trends, and business objectives.
Must-have features
- Comprehensive financial management tools (budgeting, expense tracking, savings goals, investment tracking)
- Personalised financial advice based on data analytics and machine learning algorithms
- Seamless integration with third-party financial services
- Accessibility and inclusivity, ensuring a wide range of users can benefit from the platform
Should-have features
- Specialised tools for diverse needs (e.g., irregular income management, debt reduction, retirement planning)
- Gamification and behavioural incentives to encourage better financial habits and user engagement
- Educational resources to improve financial literacy and promote financial well-being
- Multilingual support for additional languages
Could-have features
- Social sharing and community features to foster peer support and learning
- Push notifications and reminders for bill payments, savings goals, and other financial tasks
- Additional tools for specific financial tasks, such as tax planning or college savings
- Partnerships with financial institutions to offer exclusive promotions and discounts to users
Won’t-have features
- In-house wealth management services or robo-advisory features
- Physical branches or offices for in-person financial consultations
Analysis - Effort, Cost, Impact, and Dependency
Below are some samples to show the effort taken to build each feature along with the cost, value or the impact it could potentially create and the dependency across other feature sets.
Product and Tech Strategy Alignment
To develop a financial wellness app that enables faster feature rollouts and supports experiments for dynamic improvement, consider using the following technology stack and infrastructure:
Infrastructure and Platform
- Cloud Infrastructure:
- OpenShift (by Red Hat): Kubernetes container platform that provides developer and operational tools.
- Amazon Web Services (AWS): Provides a broad set of scalable services including computing power, storage, and databases.
- Alternative options: Google Cloud Platform (GCP) or Microsoft Azure.
- Containerisation:
- Docker: For creating and running application containers.
- Red Hat Universal Base Image (UBI): Provides the foundation for all certified containerized applications across the hybrid cloud.
- Container Orchestration:
- Red Hat OpenShift Kubernetes: A Kubernetes distribution that automates deployment, scaling, and management of containerized applications.
- Kubernetes: Automates deployment, scaling, and management of containerized applications.
Frontend
- Mobile App Development:
- React Native: Cross-platform framework for mobile apps.
- State Management:
- Redux: Manages and maintains app state predictably.
Backend
- Server Framework:
- Node.js with Express.js: Efficient server-side runtime for JavaScript.
- API Development:
- GraphQL: Offers flexibility in requesting data, optimizing data transfer.
Database
- Relational Database:
- PostgreSQL: Robust, open-source relational database system.
- NoSQL Database (if needed):
- MongoDB: Suitable for handling large volumes of unstructured data.
- Red Hat Data Grid: An in-memory, distributed, NoSQL datastore solution.
Data Analytics and Machine Learning
- TensorFlow or PyTorch: Open-source ML frameworks.
- Red Hat Decision Manager: For complex event processing and business rules management.
Infrastructure Management
- Configuration Management:
- Ansible (by Red Hat): Automation tool for app deployment, configuration management, and orchestration.
- Continuous Integration & Continuous Deployment (CI/CD):
- Jenkins with OpenShift Pipelines: Integration of Jenkins with OpenShift’s native CI/CD capabilities.
- Version Control:
- Git: Distributed version control system.
- Repository Hosting:
- GitHub or Bitbucket: Hosts version-controlled code repositories.
- Feature Flags:
- LaunchDarkly or Optimizely: Manage and implement feature flags.
Monitoring and Logging
- Prometheus with OpenShift Monitoring: Integrated solution for monitoring resources.
- ELK Stack or Red Hat Logging: For central logging on OpenShift environments.
Security
- OAuth or JWT: For user authentication and authorization.
- Red Hat Advanced Cluster Security for Kubernetes: Provides security for your Kubernetes environments.
Communication and Collaboration
- Red Hat AMQ: For asynchronous communication and messaging between services.
- Slack or Microsoft Teams: Team communication.
- Trello or Jira: Project management and task tracking.
- Confluence: Wiki Documentation
More Sample Scenarios
Below are some more sample scenarios that you can consider for playing this game.
Banking
Scenario | Problem | Objective |
---|---|---|
Simplifying Loan Application Process | The loan application process at a traditional bank is often lengthy, complex, and time-consuming, leading to customer dissatisfaction. | Develop a digital solution to simplify and speed up the loan application process while maintaining security and compliance standards. |
Enhancing Customer Support | Customers are often dissatisfied with long wait times and lack of personalised support from their bank’s customer service. | Design a digital solution that provides personalised, efficient, and timely customer support, improving customer satisfaction and reducing wait times. |
Financial Wellness Platform | Many customers struggle with managing their personal finances, leading to financial stress and suboptimal financial decisions. | Develop a digital solution that offers personalised financial wellness advice, budgeting tools, and goal tracking to help customers make better financial decisions and improve their overall financial health. |
Insurance
Scenario | Problem | Objective |
---|---|---|
Streamlining Claims Process | Insurance claims can be a long and complicated process, often resulting in dissatisfied customers and increased operational costs. | Create a digital solution that streamlines the claims process, reducing processing time and improving customer experience, while maintaining accuracy and compliance. |
Personalised Policy Recommendations | Customers often find it difficult to choose the right insurance policy, resulting in coverage gaps and dissatisfaction. | Develop a digital solution that analyses customer needs and preferences to provide personalised policy recommendations, ensuring better coverage and increased satisfaction. |
Customer Engagement and Retention | Insurance companies struggle with customer engagement and retention, resulting in decreased revenue and growth. | Create a digital solution that improves customer engagement and retention through personalised communication, value-added services, and incentives, leading to increased customer loyalty and long-term revenue growth. |
Public Sector
Scenario | Problem | Objective |
---|---|---|
E-Governance Solutions | Citizens often face difficulty in accessing government services, leading to inefficiencies and dissatisfaction. | Develop a digital solution that streamlines access to government services, making it easier for citizens to complete necessary tasks, access information, and interact with government agencies. |
Smart City Infrastructure | Urban areas face challenges such as traffic congestion, pollution, and inefficient resource management, affecting the quality of life for residents. | Design a digital solution that leverages IoT devices and data analytics to create a smart city infrastructure, optimising resource management, and improving urban living conditions. |
Emergency Response Optimisation | Emergency response times can be critical in life-threatening situations, but coordinating resources and personnel can be challenging. | Design a digital solution that optimises emergency response times by leveraging real-time data, advanced algorithms, and efficient communication, improving public safety and saving lives. |
Have fun!